Why Old Pixel Art Looked Better on CRT Televisions
You boot up an old favourite on a modern 4K television, a SNES classic through an official collection or an emulator, and something is off. The sprites look blocky and flat. Colours that you remember as soft gradients are hard bands.
You boot up an old favourite on a modern 4K television, a SNES classic through an official collection or an emulator, and something is off. The sprites look blocky and flat. Colours that you remember as soft gradients are hard bands. The waterfall in the background that used to shimmer now looks like a striped wallpaper. Your memory says the game was beautiful, and the screen says it was crude. Which one is lying?
Neither, quite. The art really did look different, because it was drawn for a different kind of screen. Pixel artists in the 1980s and 1990s were not painting square pixels. They were painting for the cathode ray tube, a display that blurred, blended and glowed in ways they could predict and exploit. Take that display away and you are looking at the raw ingredients rather than the finished dish.
A CRT never drew a square pixel
A consumer CRT television drew the picture with an electron beam sweeping across a phosphor coated screen, line by line, about 15,700 lines per second for an NTSC set. Consoles like the NES and SNES sent around 240 visible lines, so the beam drew each line with a dark gap of unlit glass above and below it. Those gaps are what people now call scanlines.
Within each line, the beam did not switch sharply from one colour to the next. It ramped. The signal coming from the console was usually composite or RF, which squeezed colour and brightness into one wire, and the television had to separate them again. That separation was imperfect, so neighbouring pixels bled into each other horizontally. Then the phosphors themselves, arranged as dots or stripes depending on the set, glowed with a soft bloom that spilled a little light around every bright point.
The result was a picture with no hard edges anywhere. A single pixel was a fuzzy, roughly oval glow, brighter in the middle and fading toward the sides, separated from the line above by a thin shadow.
Artists painted with the blur
The developers knew all of this, and they drew to it. The clearest example most people point to is the dithering pattern, a checkerboard of two colours. On a sharp modern display it looks like a fine grid. On a composite CRT, the horizontal bleed merges the two colours into a third. Artists on the Sega Mega Drive, which could only show a limited palette on screen at once, used this constantly to fake transparency and extra shades. The waterfalls in Sonic the Hedgehog are a famous case: vertical stripes that a composite signal smeared into a translucent sheet of water.
Eyes are another. A character sprite might be 16 pixels wide, with an eye that is one or two pixels. Drawn with a single bright pixel next to a dark one, it looks crude on a sharp screen. On a CRT, the bloom softened that bright point into a highlight, and the scanline gap gave the face a subtle sense of shading. Artists also used single pixels of intermediate colour along curves, knowing the blur would turn a staircase into a smooth arc.
I spent an afternoon with a collector in Leeds who keeps a Sony Trinitron KV-14 and a modern OLED side by side for exactly this comparison. Switching Chrono Trigger between them was a little shocking. The OLED version was perfectly sharp and looked like a spreadsheet. The Trinitron version looked like a painting.
Sharper was never the goal
The usual advice for playing old games on a new screen is to turn on the sharpest scaling you can find: integer scaling, nearest neighbour, crisp pixels. It is often sold as the most authentic option, the way the art truly is. I think that is a misunderstanding of what authenticity means here.
Crisp square pixels are how the art was stored in memory, not how anyone saw it at the time. Players in 1993 never saw those hard squares. If you want to see the game the way the artist intended, crisp scaling is arguably the least faithful option, because it strips away the very effects the art relied on.
There is a fair counterpoint. Some later games, especially on the PlayStation and Saturn with their higher resolution modes, and many PC titles viewed on sharper computer monitors, were designed for a cleaner image. And some players simply prefer crisp pixels, which is a perfectly good aesthetic choice. My only objection is calling it the original look.
How to get closer to the old look today
You have three realistic routes, from cheapest to most involved. None is perfect, and anyone who tells you a filter is identical to a real CRT has probably not stood in front of both recently.
| Option | Rough cost | What it gets right | Where it falls short |
|---|---|---|---|
| Built-in CRT filters in official collections | Free | Scanlines, some softening | Often too dark, little colour bleed |
| Shaders in RetroArch, such as CRT-Royale or Guest Advanced | Free, needs a decent GPU | Bloom, mask patterns, composite blur | Takes time to tune, adds a little lag on weak hardware |
| A real CRT television | From about 30 pounds secondhand to several hundred for broadcast monitors | Everything, including motion clarity | Heavy, ageing parts, hard to find in good condition |
For most people the RetroArch shader route is the best balance. Start with a preset that includes composite or NTSC blending, not just scanlines. Scanlines alone darken the image without merging dithered colours, which is the effect that matters most for Mega Drive games. On a 4K screen, set the game to scale to the full vertical height, then raise the screen's brightness a few notches to compensate for the mask.
If you go the real CRT route, a plain consumer set with composite input is more faithful for most 16-bit games than a sharp professional monitor. Collectors love Sony PVM and BVM monitors, but they were designed for broadcast work and show pixels more crisply than any home television did. A real tube also removes the display lag that troubles modern sets, the same issue explained in our piece on TV input lag in games, and it is the only way light gun games work, as covered in why light guns fail on modern TVs.
What to try tonight
Pick one game you know well, preferably a Mega Drive or SNES title with water or transparent effects. Play the first level with crisp scaling, then again with a composite CRT shader. Pay attention to the eyes of characters and any dithered backgrounds. Most people notice the difference within thirty seconds. More of these behind the scenes stories sit in the tech notes section.
FAQ
Why does retro pixel art look worse on modern TVs?
Because it was drawn for CRT televisions, which blurred neighbouring pixels, added scanline gaps and glowed softly. Modern screens show each pixel as a hard square, removing effects the artists relied on.
Are CRT shaders as good as a real CRT?
Good shaders come close for still images and are far more convenient. A real tube still handles motion and brightness better, but most players will be happy with a well tuned shader.
What is dithering in pixel art?
A pattern of two alternating colours, often a checkerboard, used to suggest a third colour or transparency. On a composite CRT signal the colours blended together, which was exactly the intended effect.
Should I use integer scaling for retro games?
Use it if you like crisp pixels. Just know it shows the art as stored, not as players originally saw it on a television.
More in Tech Notes
Tech Notes
Why Upscaling Makes Modern Games Look Softer on PC
A reader sent me a photograph of his monitor last month with a note that said something is wrong with my eyes or my graphics...
Tech Notes
How Online Games Rewind Time to Decide Who Shot First
You stepped out from behind the wall, saw the enemy, fired, watched the blood effect, and then your screen went grey and the...
Tech Notes
HDMI Handshake Failures and How to Find the Cause
The console was on. The television said no signal. Ten seconds later the picture arrived, held for four seconds, went black...